I felt like I was ready to shatter into a million pieces under Roxy's curious gaze. Desperately, I began trying to think of a response without giving my identity away. "Uhh...I dunno. Probably not", I fibbed unconvincingly. Beth's attention soon turned away from her phone and she tilted her head up to look at the commotion going on next to her. A sadistic smile appeared across her face.
"Who's this, Peter?", Beth asked in an innocent voice, as if she was completely unaware of what she was doing.
The fact that she called me Peter seemed like it was an intentional choice. Not once since these humiliating games of sissification began had she ever referred to me by my actual name, and it was clear she was trying to expose me. I watched in horror as a knowing look suddenly began to appear across Roxy's face. It was the kind of look someone gets when they finally figure out the answer too difficult riddle, or discover who the perpetrator was in a game of who-done-it. I began to get the feeling that my worst nightmares were quickly going to become a reality.
"Peter? Wait a minute...I do know you! You're Peter Anderson, the guy who sits across from me in Ms. Hazel's Geometry class!", Roxy said excitedly. "You're the shy one, right? The one who doesn't really talk to anyone? What the heck are you doing here dressed like this?"
My body began to shake nervously. "Well, you know...I lost a bet. It's just part of a silly game, that's all!", I managed to answer despite the apparent nervousness in my voice. All I could think about at that moment was getting as far away from this place as possible. Unfortunately, I was too much of a wuss to make a break for it.
Beth let out a small giggle and patted me on the head. "Oh come on sissy, you know it's rude to lie to strangers", she said, before turning to Roxy and continuing, "Our little Buttercup practically begged us to dress him up like this and take him to see Princess Brittney perform later. Britteny is his favorite performer of all time. He has all her posters and everything. We know he doesn't have many friends at school so we try to indulge him and make him happy from time to time. It's what he wants, really." The fact that Beth would lie and throw me under the bus like that made me furious. Especially since I'd been complying with her every demand so far.
I expected Roxy to laugh, but instead she just raised one eyebrow and began studying me more closely. "Right...kind of weird but okay..." she pondered aloud. Her eyes seemed to eventually land on the lower regions of my skirt, causing me to sweat nervously in terror. I didn't know how obvious my diapers were, but I was beginning to think they might not be as well hidden as I had initially thought. My suspicions would soon be proven correct when Roxy grabbed the edge of my pink frilly skirt and pulled it up, fully revealing the entirety of my embarrassing white padding. She placed a hand over her mouth and gasped. "Oh my god how cute! Baby even has a nice pair of pampers. I suppose these were his idea as well?"
"No, I take full credit for that one!", came an amused voice from behind Roxy. She turned around to find Jenna returning with two hot dogs, handing one to her sister and placing the other at her spot on the bench. With her hands now freed, she extended one arm to greet the red haired teen and formally introduced herself. "My name's Jenna, and that's my sister Beth. I'm guessing you probably already know little Buttercup here. What's your name?"
Roxy accepted Jenna's request for a handshake and returned one in kind. "My name's Roxy. I'm a classmate of Pete's. Although I don't really know him all that well...clearly." Roxy responded while shooting questionable looks in my direction. It was like she was still trying to figure out what to make of me. Either way, she seemed highly amused. She continued, "I was here waiting for my shift to begin as a stagehand in the Princess in the Park event later this afternoon, when I saw Pete from across the food court and thought that he looked familiar. Is this a regular thing for you guys? I won't lie, it's kind of weird, but he honestly looks kind of adorable. Pathetic as all hell, don't get me wrong, but also very cute."
My face grew more and more red as I sat there listening to the girl of my dreams talk to my captors about me as if I truly was a little toddler girl. I wanted to speak up and defend myself, but what could I possibly say? The proof was in the pudding, and it would be impossible to get her to unsee something like this. It didn't take a genius to figure out that our chances of being together just went from slim to none.
Jenna began digging around inside of the diaper bag before pulling out two large containers of gerber baby food. When I saw them I gulped in anticipation, knowing what was probably going to happen next. Jenna continued to chat casually as she unsealed one of the containers and began preparing for my very public feeding. "She does make a very cute baby girl, doesn't she? Me and Beth have been dressing Pete up in pretty outfits since he was a little boy. We probably started when he was about four years old or so. Honestly I think he loves it as much as we do. It's only recently that we decided that he'd be better off as a big baby, though. Don't you think it suits him well? He certainly acts like a baby sometimes."
Roxy giggled and nodded. "Oh yeah, it definitely suits him well alright. I always thought Pete might be kind of gay, mostly because I've never seen him with a girl, but I never figured he was this much of a sissy. I guess it makes sense though. Is this what you want, Pete? Do you want to be a pretty princess and wear diapers like a baby?"
Seeing Roxy so amused by my misfortune made my eyes well up with tears. "No, it's not like that Roxy. I don't want this at all", I tried to beg and plead. "They made me dress up like this. I'm not a sissy, I...mmphp!" Suddenly, I found myself being muffled by the force of a small plastic spoon full of baby food. The lukewarm mush felt absolutely disgusting in my mouth.
"Shhh...be quiet and eat your food while the adults are talking, princess", Jenna commanded as she continued to spoon feed helping after helping of baby food into my mouth. Roxy shook her head and laughed upon seeing how easily I was able to be tamed by my two beautiful cousins. I don't know if she had any respect for me to begin with, but after seeing how easily I had let them expose me to humiliation after humiliation, I was willing to bet that any small ammount of respect she could have possibly had for me was gone. Small tears began to fall down my face as I sat there listening to Jenna, Beth, and Roxy idly chat away about my entire predicament while I sat there forced to endure the act of being fed like a toddler in front of the entire zoo. Eventually the first container had been completely emptied, and it was time for me to consume my second entire helping of baby food.
I then saw Roxy get a mischievous look on her face as she saw Jenna begin to unseal the second jar of food. "Hey, mind if I feed her? I babysit a lot, so I have lots of experience." Jenna happily agreed and handed the feeding supplies over to Roxy, who sat down next to me close enough that I could get a good look down her shirt. Although I tried as hard as I could not to look, the sight of her large breasts underneath her loose black t-shirt caused my tiny pen-is to begin growing hard. To be honest, I think she may have noticed, but I highly doubt she cared. Roxy dug one spoonful of brightly colored mush out of the glass container and brought it to my lips. "It's time for more num nums, Buttercup!", she teased in a sing-songy kind of voice, before pushing the spoon into my mouth for a second helping. The way she said my nickname, I could tell she was beginning to have fun with this in a similar way to my cousins. By the time I was done eating, my entire face was covered in disgusting orange-yellow mush, just like an uncoordinated baby that has trouble feeding themself.
"Awww that was really nice, what a good little baby you are", Roxy said with a friendly pat on my diaper as she handed the empty jar and spoon back to Jenna. "But you two should really think about getting your little baby a bib. Her face is absolutely nasty!" The three of them laughed and agreed that a bib would definitely be a necessity from now on, since I was obviously such a messy eater. By the time Jenna began wiping down my face with a baby wipe, Roxy realised that she had to begin setting up for the Princess in the Park event, but kindly let Jenna and Beth know that she would be happy to babysit for them any time, and that if we wanted to see her again after the show we were more than happy to. Finally, before leaving for good Roxy pulled out her phone and took a selfie of her and I with my entire face in full view of the camera. Whatever happened from here on out, I was certain my secret was no longer safe, and I began to panic for what the future might bring.